crapnotshit 10:43 Sun Sep 21
Toons want Carroll back
|
|
According to BBC, Newcastle are interested in Carroll.
Would you, and to what price?
|
|
|
Replies - In Chronological Order ( Show Newest Messages First)
Orange Hammer
10:45 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
If we got our money back, a big yes. As long as it was invested back in the squad.
|
frank marker
10:52 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
£18 11s 6d
|
teacoffeeteacoffee
10:58 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
No. We should stick with him and try to make it work, he is still only 25 and can still be a hero here. If Toon were to offer silly money then of course you would have to consider it, but I highly doubt that will happen. 10 mil tops I reckon.
|
crapnotshit
11:01 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
£15-20m
YES
|
Alex V
11:05 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Obviously Sam would be totally against a sale. But it would equally obviously totally make sense for the club. Time to move on, get the club's injury-prone highest earner off the books. It depends where we are in the table in January though.
|
goose
11:09 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Anything above £10 then he's all yours.
|
Roby
11:09 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
When he's fit they will chuck him straight back in and put Sakho on the bench.
His fee wasn't the problem but rumoured wages of £90k per week for a player who hardly ever plays and doesn't score many when he does is worrying.
|
goose
11:09 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Or £10m.
|
Willtell
11:10 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Sakho is running riot at the moment but like Cisse at Newcastle will dry up soon then return hungry again later.
Football is a squad game and unless Newcastle offer us at least the £15m - £19m we paid, why sell when we will need another striker who may not be as good....
|
bishbosh
11:16 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Sticking Carroll in will ruin the rhythm of the team your have him and Valencia jumping for the same balls
We will have to resort to long ball again when he comes back sakho has been superb since being brought in 3 games in 3 games if he continues this form Carroll should just be up as an impact sub a plan b etc
|
Sxboy_66
11:16 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
They probably want him back as manager. Deluded cunts that they are.
|
mentor
11:21 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
When he's fully fit wtf would we want to sell him?
|
Iron Duke
11:23 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
I like Carroll and think he could still be a great player, but let's face it, it hasn't really worked out for him. If Newcastle were serious and Carroll wanted to go, I would probably take £10m for him, with a few add ons for appearances / sel on fees, etc.
|
Far Cough
11:25 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
It depends on who the next manager is, Pardew seems to be a dead man walking at the moment?
|
mentor
11:30 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
A choice of Valencia, Sakho and Carroll or a choice between Valencia, Sakho and Cole?
|
Full Claret Jacket
11:34 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Willtell 11:10 Sun Sep 21
I have to agree. We can't expect the likes of Valencia and Sakho to go the whole season being fit and as effective. Teams will find ways to stop them unless they turn out exceptional world class players.
We might need to throw a big man on and play differently in some games or to change a game but I don't think he fits the style we are currently playing.
Will he want to sit on the bench though when fit and can the club afford to play big wages to a player who isn't getting starts and being effective?
I think it's a good problem to have but hope our current strike force go from strength to strength.
|
theaxeman
11:36 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Let him go, he will only dictate our style of play, has no pace either so cant stretch the game
|
teacoffeeteacoffee
11:36 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
Far Cough - It won't matter who the gaffer is if Ashley wants him back.
|
Sven Roeder
11:39 Sun Sep 21
Re: Toons want Carroll back
|
He is needed as an option amongst our strikers and obviously you need more than 2.
If they were to offer the £35m they received then we would take it though.
We don't need to sell so only silly offers should be considered.
|
| 
